A MEMORIAL SERVICE WAS HELD ON SAT. MARCH 28TH, 2009 AT BATTELL CHAPEL, Yale University, at 3:00pm. All were cordially invited. Over 800 in attendance! DVD available through the Yale Glee Club office.

Service details: Tom Murray, University Organist, started the prelude 20 minutes before the 3 p.m. service began. There were performances by The Yale Glee Club, The Yale Alumni Chorus, The Whiffenpoofs of 2009, The SLOT's, and The University Glee Club of New Haven. A magnificent, and humbling, tribute.

Contributions in memory of Fenno may be sent to the
North Congregational Church P.O. Box 307 New Hartford CT 06057.

Condolences may be sent directly to the family (Carol, Sarah, Lucy, Peggy, Terry) at pogilvy@comcast.net

Search This Blog

F F Heath Jr. 12-30-1926 to 12-05-2008



About the blog:
Please feel free to share your memories with us about Fenno/Dad. Send your stories/memories to pogilvy@comcast.net and we will gladly post your letter, unless you indicate otherwise.

Thank you. Your letters bring us joy.

Sincerely,

~Carol, Sarah, Lucy, Peggy, and Terry Heath


Saturday, December 6, 2008

blog post

Hi,

I'm sure I can't say anything as eloquent and heartfelt as the prior
posters, but I do feel compelled to write. Although I had a very
meaningful experience at Yale, few things have left me with as
powerful and positive memories as my time with Fenno and the Ugly Club
(that's what my family always thought I was saying).

Thank you Fenno and thank you Heaths for sharing him with us.

Michael Littman, '88
(Publicity Officer '87, Historian '88, Bass to this very day)

From Sue Quimby Young, Fenno's Niece

I read with great sadness of my Uncle Fenno passing
yesterday. My daughter and I have been amazed by all the
letters and stories. I have learned so much about his life
that i was unaware of. What wonderful memories! While we
were most certainly not the Yale Glee Club, he did write a
few songs that his nieces and nephews sang together while
up in New Hampshire......a round about making maple syrup
called "Hot Syrup" (that went great with my grandmother's
DONUTS!!) and my favorite..."My Grandfather Had A Skunk
Under His Barn". What a sense of humor!! These songs are
so very firmly planted in my and my brothers' heads. I
sing them at times to my classes of 2 year olds at
Dartmouth Childcare. His children's music will continue to
be spread!

Susan Quimby Young, Fenno's Niece

Composer, Conductor, Teacher

Composer, conductor, teacher (with the greatest of teacher's gifts, as others have noted, the ability to know every one of us as individuals and recall us decades later without the slightest hesitation), colleague, friend, husband and father-- there's also Fenno the arranger. At a Whiff reunion some years back, three alums took the stage to announce that in the car on the way, they had found that Fenno's arrangement of "September Song" worked even with one part missing. They proceeded to knock us all out by showing how very true that was. By way of explanation, their spokesman observed, "Well, it's Fenno". No more needed to be said.
Now the heavenly choirs are pulling up their socks, clearing their throats, and getting ready to sing as they've never sung before. Fenno and family, I hope you are feeling the love and the gratitude just pouring in.

Lewis Girdler, '61

There Will Never Be Another Fenno

Dear Fenno and Carol,

You are all in our thoughts and hopes in the days ahead, as we think about a wonderfully lived and fully accomplished life and a truly fine human being.

Fenno, you have enriched my musical existence for well over 50 years. From the Liebeslieder waltzes in the Apollo glee club in 1949, to the day in 1950 when you and some close-harmony singers invaded the Saybrook dining hall, to singing Cascade in Washington four years ago, and right up to to this moment. Dozens of Yale Glee Club concerts in New Haven and on the road. The unforgettable rehearsals and performances of The Birds in 1952. A Glee Club concert you led in Paris in the 1970s. Then there are songs and arrangements, like Liza, that you may not have thought about for years. So many great moments. It was my great luck and privilege to have sung with and learned from you.

But those are personal feelings. Much more important is what you have done for music at Yale and for Yale itself, and the testimony is everywhere. With due respect to others, there will never be another Fenno.

John Trattner, 1952

A Truly Memorable Man

Dear Carol and Family,

I have just read through the blog with both sadness and many good memories. I believe that along with Dick Smith '54 I was one of Fenno's first two Bursary Students in the YGC offices, serving there 1952-54. At first Barty was still around and my YGC Songbook is signed by both of them. I also had the privilege of going on the 1954 European Tour at which we came in second among the male choruses at the huge festival in Wales, also visiting Elihu Yale's church. Fenno used to point to that runner-up prize as an example of the supreme importance of paying attention to how a piece of music was supposed to be performed. One of the compulsory pieces was about a Scottish chief; we sang it perfectly but according to the judges too fast - it was supposed to be more like a dirge! There is a photograph in the booklet on that tour showing Fenno being carried on our shoulders.

Your forwarded message was a sad thing to receive, but I hope your sadness is eased a little by all this outpouring of affection with the passing of a truly memorable man.

Ogden D. Miller, Jr. '55

Peace and love

Dear Fenno and family,

I have just been reading the postings on the blog and am overwhelmed. Fenno was such a big part of so many of our lives at Yale, and I just can't imagine the place without him. I am so grateful for the day I got up the courage to go put my name on the audition list at Hendrie Hall - and that I was blessed with such a common name. I might not have made the Glee Club had I not been the third Susan Williams to try out. My time in the Glee Club is one of my fondest memories of Yale. Fenno, you were a mentor and a friend and I will miss you. And yes, we are all sorry about the time a group of us talked our way into some museum in some Midwestern town by promising to sing in front of the I-max screen and you told us we should not advertise ourselves as the Yale Glee Club unless all of us were there. Peace and love.

Susan (Louise) Williams '86

"When We Were Here Together"

Dear Fenno, Carol and family,
I've been tracking Fenno's progress through your e-mails and now the blog. What a good idea the blog is for all of us.

Lately I've been leafing through Fenno's "When We Were Here Together", his delightful recollections of his years as YGC Director. It's stunning how many lives he enriched with singing, and it's amazing how many people are still singing! There's just nothing like it, and Fenno knows that best.

One of the luckiest things that ever happened to me was meeting Fenno when he came to The Loomis School. He, Nate Pierpont and I, along with some other friends started the Pelicans, a singing group that is still going strong. That was in 1943! All these years later, after singing together in the Elm St. Eight, Whiffs, Glee Clubs, we are still pals and singing buddies with the SLOTS. I just feel so privileged to have known him and Carol and the whole family. What a joy!

Lolly and I send our love and best wishes. Thanks for everything.

- Bruce & Lolly Barton

Peace

Et Fenno caro factum est. Et habitavit in nobis.

Fenno lives on in all of us.

Geoff Buchan YGC '91
Dawn Sedgwick Buchan YGC '93

My Most Favorite Choral Conductor

Fenno:

You have always been my most favorite choral conductor, the perfect blend of person, musician and teacher, who always welcomed every singer of any level of ability as a friend. I originally came from the instrumental side of the music world, and when I took your choral conducting class you used to call me the 'band director' until I took your teachings to heart. The Glee Club sound has inspired some of my own work. I only sang in the Glee Club in my Senior year, but the ever expanding Glee Club world (Associates, YAC, etc.) has grown to be the main way I connect to Yale. It has truly been a pleasure.

David Barnett '78

FENNO THANKS FOR THE PURPOSE OF LIFE

I must admit that I lack the appropriate words to describe the overwhelming sense of love and appreciation surrounding Mr. Heath even as he embark on a difficult jorney.The love of his sweetheart Carol, the care of his children Terry,Sarah,Lucy,Peggy and the pride of his grandchildren is admirable. So touching is the multitudes of his admirers all across the world sending their love on the blog which are read to him, As a hospice caregiver who has seen scores of families went through this journey with their loved ones, this experience is one of a kind that not only re-emphasize our true purpose on this earth: to live it better than we found it but also affect the lives of as many people as possible as Fenno appears to have achieved. I pray and hope that I am not the only one who have learn from this experience but I hope we are all challenged in our small ways to try positively to affect other people without looking for what we can receive in return.

CAROL, Terry and The Heath Sisters, you are doing a great job, the4 cheer up even in this seemingly difficult time. I am honored to see this and I believe when the time comes, your father will be welcomed by the HGC- The Heavenly Glee Club

Attah Buatsi

Friday, December 5, 2008

What a gift

Fenno. The definition…of a great conductor, a great teacher, and a great man, kind and good.

Dear Fenno,

You, Carol, and your loving family are in the hearts of all who were blessed to know you and to sing under your direction.

Filled with love and joy for music, you imparted these qualities to us. Unfailingly gracious, generous, and noble in the face of the challenges involved, you inspired us to reach for some transcendent goal that we did not know we could reach until we had done it.

Your masterpieces of composition, so many arrangements of great insight and profound respect for the material at hand---singing these with you made the experience all the more personal. Your ingenious conducting technique - an elegant ballet that swept delighted choristers up and into the many sound worlds that you created, filled with magic and crackling with electrical sparks.

Oh, Fenno! To once again be singing with you, to feel the entire chorus rising to meet the demands of your gestures and directions. To feel once again the surging power of those FFF sections, and the instant swoops to PPP, all riding as it were on the wings of song. But really on the wings of your technique and musical knowledge. And your brilliant wit.

What a gift, dearest Fenno, what a gift you have been to all who know you.

With deepest love and admiration,
Warren H Rothman, ‘65

Forever Grateful

Dear Fenno,
 
You have always been such an inspiration to me. In any concert setting, I invariably found myself ready to place my musical well-being in your talented hands. It didn't seem to matter how well I remembered the music or words. You were somehow able to extract the best I had to offer.
 
I'll always remember that moment at Boston Symphony Hall when our soloist forgot the words and you covered the gap with your own voice, and the audience never knew. Wow!!!
 
I'm forever grateful for your wonderful friendship over the years, and your many kindnesses.
 
Marv Berenblum, YGC, '54-56

Important part of our Yale years

To all Heaths,

Fenno and the Glee Club were such an important part of our Yale years,
that many of us (even having sung his retirement concert) have
difficulty thinking of the chorus as having any other director. I am
thankful to have had the rare opportunity to sing with him for so many
years.

He has touched my life deeply, as he has those of several generations of
Yale singers.  I love him and miss him and hold all of you in my
thoughts and prayers.

Karen Schoenberger

Greatest gift, the gift of song

Dear Fenno,
 
When I was at Yale, you gave me the greatest gift, the gift of song. I hadn't realized then that it would be such an important part of my life. I had arrived at Yale in 1971 and, although I had sung in my highschool choir, I didn't pursue singing at Yale until I was a junior. I'm not sure why I ventured down to Hendrie Hall to audition for the Yale Glee Club in the fall of my junior year, but I did. I remember that you seemed sort of surprised. I guess by junior year most people were either singing or not. You asked me why I was there, and I said I realized that I really wanted to sing. I don't even think the audition went that well because I remember you said my sightreading wasn't the best, but I had a good ear. I'm sure there were plenty of other "younger" kids that you could have taken (there was no Freshman Glee Club at that time, so there were probably many freshmen auditioning), but you took me. Perhaps it was because I said I really wanted to sing. And for that I am forever grateful. I made my best friends in the Glee Club (do you remember what a duo Leslie Fitzpatrick and I were?!) and I haven't stopped singing since.
 
For most of my adult life, I have lived in Norfolk, Conn., where music at Yale was really born. I have walked on the paths that the Battells and Stoeckels walked on along the Village Green and sung in the church where they sang, as I know you have too. When Robbins Battell introduced the singing of English glees to northwest Connecticut and supported Gustave Stoeckel at Yale, he began a proud tradition which continues today. I am so grateful to have been a part of this tradition. Singing has brought so much meaning and beauty into my life. I don't think I can ever thank you enough.
 
With love,
 
Ann
 
Ann Havemeyer
Yale College, Class of 1975

Legacy Lives On...

I sang under Fenno from 1976-1979 and took choral conducting from him as an "independent study."  Please let him know he was loved and that I have kept up my choral conducting to this day.  I presently conduct a 45-voice men's barbershop chorus in Appleton, Wisconsin.
 
I want him to know that his legacy lives on...
 
Bill Albrecht
Class of 1979

Immeasurable Thanks

Dear Fenno,

Thank you from me, as well, another of the many thousands whose lives you touched. You taught me how to make music with care, love, and fellowship--many of my dearest friendships are forever wound up with memories of your gentle, generous conducting and all the wonderful times I had in the Glee Club. I offer immeasurable thanks, and wish you much peace.

--Harriet Goren '83

Indelible Memory

Dear Fenno -
 
You were a huge part of my Yale experience, and happy memories from two years there as a graduate student. The 1977 Tour was a highlight of my life, and one indelible memory must be of my imitating your conducting in the basement of a concert venue in Dachau prior to giving that evening's concert. I couldn't look you too closely in the eye during that performance for fear of cracking both of us up. I love your spirit and sense of fun, and have been happy to see you several times in intervening years for a variety of reasons.
 
You are a dear person - thank you for lots of happy times, and much LOVE!
 
Polly Willard Marvin

Important Influence

Fenno (and Carol and Terry):
I know I have been out of touch these past 2 decades or so, but I want you all to know how important you were to me back in the 1980s. I had the privilege of watching Terry do the Hustle with Laurie Newman, of driving with Carol and Fenno up to Torrington, and of having dinner with Fenno's mom at her house. I was able to sing under Fenno's care in both Battelle Chapel choir and Glee Club, and to participate in the Scandanavian tour of 1987 (as well as many US tours). In short, I was honored out of all measure by all of you, and I want to tell Fenno, especially, that he was a very important influence in my life. I hope I am to my students at Swarthmore what he was to his at Yale.

My love to all of you, and deepest sadness for the news that Fenno is ill.

Carr Everbach

Real Inspiration

Dear Fenno,
 
What a joy it is to quickly let you know the impact you had on me 20 years ago. I joined the Glee Club primarily to be close to a girl. In two years you opened my eyes to the beauty of music, to the beauty of singing. I still have shivers remembering singing your folk songs and the Biebl, in particular. While the songs were beautiful your passion for them was the real inspiration. Your passion for the music and for us brought the best out of me. You gave me the gift of song and I am a better person for it. I will tell my grandchildren about singing for Fenno!
Baker Mallory '91

Thanks for the Momories

"Thanks for the Momories"..."Mary Don't Dig Me" (Heath Lament, circa 1950)-will pass and be forgotten with very few others! 
 
Bart Miller

Yale .vs. Harvard

To The Heath Family:
I was an early teen ager in the mid 50's when my father (Harvard '39) announced that the family was going to New Haven for the Harvard-Yale football game (notice I said Harvard-Yale). We were to overnight at some out of town motel on Friday and Saturday, and then I was informed that we were all going to the Harvard-Yale Glee Club concert on Friday night.
As the concert started, the Harvard Glee Club sang first. I was a newly self-discoverd singer and lover of classical music, so this was a new, eye-opening treat for me.

I thought the Harvard Glee Club sang beautifully. "How could anyone sing better than that", I mused as the Yale Glee Club entered on stage. Of course, there was an underlying competitive spirit within as I was preparing to go to the Yale Bowl the next day and scream for Harvard.

Well, a funny thing happend. I saw this guy named Heath rise to the podium and embark on a selection of anthems and songs and I was totally spell-bound. I remember feeling that I was being taken into "another place". I could not help thinking (as hard as I tried not to) that this chorus was better than Harvard's. I kept trying trying to suppress the thought, but I was swept into that other world to which only good music could take you. And to top it off, Yale sang without music, Harvard sang with music! I began to realize that Yale had defeated Harvard, at least on that Friday night.

I had the pleasure of watching Fenno conduct numerous times after that, almost always in those memorable Friday concerts.It pushed me towards allocating much of my time into singing (and some conducting).

And, 2 years ago, I sort of came full circle after 50 years and joined the Yale (ahem, that's correct, Yale) Alumni Chorus on their tour of the Netherlands and their Beethoven 9th concert with Maestro Gergiev.

After my first memorable experience that Friday in New Haven, even during my undergraduate years at Harvard, I always had a little sense of comparative inferiority when I was listening to the Yale Glee Club.

But I still point towards that first concert in New Haven where the Yale Glee Club beat Harvard and turned me on to a life of such immense pleasure. I will never forget it.

God bless him.

Tim Russell '66

Dear Fenno:

 

You may not remember me, but I sang in the Glee Club from 1975-78, and was a music major, Janne Newland (I now go by Juanita Newland Ulloa).

Your spirit, both in the Glee Club and in conducting class was always masterful, spirited and elegant. I remember I was too scared to conduct, actually, but I greatly admired you.

I  am now a Latin American mariachi singer/songwriter and Professor of Voice and Ethnomusicology at Texas State University. I came back to Yale and sang a solo in Glee Club at a reunion 3 or so years ago.  You said it was quite  a novel sound for you.  I know my style is not traditional Glee Club sound, but it was fun anyway!

 

I am sure your influence is part of what has given me a wonderful music career, and I thank you from the bottom of my heart.  Plus you are very handsome!  I will always remember you.

 

My best to you and your family,

Juanita Ulloa

 

 

Bridged

Peggy and all the Heaths -- my thoughts and prayers are with you all during this time.  Fenn has had such a truly wonderful impact on so many thousands.  I count myself lucky to have sung in the YGC in the 1980s, and to have known a wonderful Yale musician who bridged so many singing generations. 
 
With love for you all,
Sarah Holmes

From Kem Edwards

So, where is the Fennoism that gets the most raucous response....."As Robert Shaw said ________".


Fill in the blanks!

Kem Edwards '49

A circle of song

Dear Fenno,
 
A circle of song
Stretches the world,
Round you, round us,
Gossamer thin, light,
But tight,
Fiercely strong.
 
This circle of song
Wrapped round my heart
Etched into memory
Cannot be erased.
 
We pass it along
To those next in line,
As the circle expands
In my son's open face:
Generations to come,
Both in time,
And in space.
 
You shine at the core.
(Lift white hankies high)
Aloft yet entwined
We sing "Winds of night…".
 
Thank you always,
Dawn
 
Dawn M. Ellis
YGC '88-'89, officer
 

"Keep calmly knowing change." from Mary Boyle

Mary Boyle said...

Dearest Fenno, Carol, Sarah, Lucy, Terry, and Peggy,

Thank you for allowing me to be with you as we witness the process of life.

"Keep calmly knowing change." This reverberates as I prepare myself, too, with an aging father.

It is such a gift to read the many posts from Yale Glee Club members as I learn more about a past I was not part of but have helped me piece together those memories you cherish and connect them with the most current 12 years of Cornstock events in Cornish, New Hampshire: Fenno reading "Fern Hill" and The Heath Sisters singing "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" and Terry setting up the fireworks display, and Carol playing wonderful contra dance music or leading us to parade The Plainfield Yankee Doodlers in "This Land is Your Land" and "Yankee Doodle."

Magic, music, and wonder. You are a wonderful family.

Love, M

The Road Is Calling

Dear Fenno,
From the day in the Fall of 1973 that you asked me to sing "Aura Lee" for you at my audition…to the last time you led our singers at the Celebration in Woolsey Hall, you've been an important part of my life.  But I am just one soprano, and not a very good one at that.  There are so many people whose lives would have been different had they not met you.  There is also your music, which is everywhere.  When the Whiffenpoofs sing "A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square" in white tie and tails, it is present.  When three guys driving up to New Haven practice "Autumn Song" to perform at reunions, it is present.  When yet another audience hears "Little Lamb" for the first time, in all of its achingly beautiful simplicity, it is present.  You will always be part of this world, even though – as your friend John Krumm wrote – "The road is calling as leaves are falling, it's back to home, my travels are all done.  We'll sit by the fire and drink a toast to all of you.  Farewell, I must be gone."
 
---------------------------------------
Jennifer L. Julier '77
Assistant Director, Association of Yale Alumni
              (203) 436-8014      
              (203) 432-0587        (fax)

Fenno, Carol & Hendrie Hall

 

Dear Fenno, Carol, and Heath Family,  

 

What do I remember?  I remember Carol sitting at the back of Hendrie Hall, knitting, nodding her head with the music, and looking up every now and then.  I remember Fenno waving his arms in front of us, a bi-weekly ritual to wake us from our post-prandial stupor, to inspire us to sound worthy of the pictures on those walls, the history in that room, the music itself.  I joined the Glee Club in my senior year, 1991-1992, an quietly opinionated violinist who had never completely understood “choristers.”  Why did I jump the orchestra ship to join the choir?  Because of Fenno.  It was his last year as music director of the YGC, and I knew even then that this was an opportunity to last a lifetime.  Here was somebody whose light I wanted to shine on me.  My emotional attachment to Yale is primarily through the songs of the Glee Club.  My fondest memories of Yale are of learning to sing with a group, learning to be a musician with my voice, and Fenno has everything to do with that. 

 

With Carol’s constant presence – whether in Hendrie Hall or not – and Fenno’s boundless energy and devotion to this organization and to each of us, they created an enormous family – of hundreds?  thousands? – built around music, love, and affection.  My consolation today in contemplating his passing, is that he has left to us his music on the page, in our hearts and in our minds.  For anyone else that would be a cliché.  Not for Fenno.  And because this is the Glee Club, we can be sure that when our voices become strong, we will raise them joyfully.               

 

Thank you, Fenno for giving so much of yourself to so many.  Thank you, Heath Family, for sharing Fenno with us for so many years. 

 

We are everlastingly grateful.

 

Michelle Brazier

1992

 

Knit and Crochet

I love you Fenno, and I thank the Heath Family for sharing themselves with us over the years. And Carol, the Altos still knit and crochet with you -- I can still hear Fenno say "Put those Goddamn needles down!!" followed by Carol's calm response, "Keep going, Girls."

Sandra L. Davis '92

With Love and Respect

The Yale experience and the Fenno experience are inextricably linked. All of us at one time or another were afraid of Fenno -- Lord knows that man could make the paint chip off Hendrie's walls if he wanted to with a shout, a whisper or even one of the famous looks. However, everything came from a point of love and wanting to bring out the best in the music and our voices.

Fenno graciously gave me $500 toward tour because he knew I did not have the funds. The fact that he made the process virtually painless was greatly appreciated -- only years later did he tell me he knew that I was scared to ask him. However, it came with a Fenno warning; "If you are late, even one minute late to one rehearsal, you're out." Well, one day I woke up late and had minutes to make it to Hendrie -- no time to change out of PJ's. I ran all the way to Hendrie and then faced the dreaded stairwell that could make even the best Glee Clubber late. I climbed those stairs and made it inside to the Glee Club room with seconds to spare -- that metal folding chair never felt so good. Fenno looked down, saw my jammies/winded demeanor and said, "Hello, Sandra" as if nothing had happened. Then he gave me a genuine Fenno smile with that curve of the lip.

Fenno was always a supporter of women's voices at Yale -- from his arrangements for Proof of the Pudding and Whim to all the behind the scenes work that few knew about and many benefitted from; that is part of his living legacy. When we travelled to Harvard for the joint Glee Club concerts, he reminded us to "Let the crowd know why we have women and they don't."

As a person who has zero sight reading skills, I was able to look at Fenno all the time and cherish the faces -- OH ALL THOSE FACES -- that he made. And watching Fenno in a concert was a true joy. He brought out the best in us and gave so much through sharing himself. Over the years, I have been very thankful for wonderful interactions and conversations with our dear Fenno.

My strong faith tells me that when Fenno is called Home, he will be welcomed by angel choruses -- but there will be resounding voices from earth below from all of his friends and family singing. Fenno will simply smile and know, that's his YGC!!!

I love you Fenno, and I thank the Heath Family for sharing themselves with us over the years. And Carol, the Altos still knit and crochet with you -- I can still hear Fenno say "Put those Goddam needles down!!" followed by Carol's calm response, "Keep going, Girls."
Sandra L. Davis '92

Helmuth Rilling

Dear Fenno,

A few thoughts run through my mind as I contemplate your passage into a more peaceful world:

You will always live on as a part of me. The Glee Club was the best experience of my undergraduate days, and you personified the Glee Club. I made my closest Yale friends in Hendrie Hall and on tour buses. You taught me to love singing, and to love music.

Today I continuously hum "The Ash Grove," a tune that you helped me arrange for 4-part chorus during my junior year. You have been an extraordinarily gifted composer and arranger.

You have had such courage! You recognized that when Yale admitted women, the Glee Club should do the same. You endured a few rough years, but you persevered. All women who have ever sung in the Glee Club owe a debt to your foresight.

Last April, when Helmuth Rilling came to Yale to conduct Mendelssohn's Elijah, I was thrilled to see you in the balcony of Woolsey Hall before the performance. I sang my heart out for you that night, just as I sang for you all those years ago in the Glee Club. I will continue to sing for you, as long as I live.

With love and affection,
Laurie (Hasselmann) Ongley
YCG '81

Fenno

So many firsts, Fenno,
I remember the audible gasps of Yale Club old-timers on one tour when YGC's women stolled out onto the stage to sing ("My GOD, there are more women than men!"), and the tepid applause for our incredible soloist - a black man who, like Fenno, ignored their subtle and not-so-subtle rebukes. How far we have come, and in no small thanks to Fenno's courage in making music 'harmonious' in so many ways.

In 1981, a small group of senior women, most of us Glee Clubbers, decided to try to start a senior women's accapella group. At the time, there was nothing like the Whiffs for women, and we thought it was time. There was plenty of skepticism that it would catch on, not least of which among this small group of women. The one who didn't show any skepticism or hesitation was Fenno. Fenno helped us, supported us, provided us with practice space, encouragement, and I think later arranged for the group. That year, Whim 'n Rhythm was born. When we sang 25 years later with the Glee Club and other groups at a reunion event, it was like coming home. Mother of Men is cool. Father of Whim 'n...well, that deserves some credit, too. Thank you for believing in us, and in the power of music to bridge differences and knit people together. We never have, and never will, forget everything you have done for us. We love you, Fenno, and the wonderful family you shared with us, too.

Julie Iffland, '81.

Reminded of Fenno ...

There are certain pieces that take me right back to Hendrie, Woolsey, and Battell with Fenno. The Hindemith Six Chansons. The Brahms Requiem. Barber's Reincarnations. And all of Fenno's wonderful settings of Walt Whitman.
 
A few special moments: On the Winter Tour during the first year that women were in the Glee Club, we began at the Yale Club in New York City (to which my female classmates were not invited to join), and we did NOT begin the concert with "Mother of Men." There was gasping and general apoplexy among the Old Blues. I think Fenno took as much heat as Kingman Brewster did for going co-ed. The standard rejoinder was that "Parent of Persons" just didn't have the same ring.
 
The year after Stokowski was given the Howland Prize, he invited a "chorus from Yale" to sing Beethoven's Ninth in Carnegie Hall. Fenno auditioned all the singers, who came out of the woodwork for the opportunity. At the end of my audition, Fenno said, "You have a high A. For a tenor in this piece, that's all you need. You're in." He taught us the piece, and Stokowski came to Hendrie for one rehearsal. In the middle of it, he suddenly stopped and said to his assistants, "These singers are wonderful. Where are we?" "We're in New Haven, maestro. This is the Yale Glee Club Room." Fenno just rolled his eyes.
 
During rehearsals for some piece with a lot of sixteenth-note runs (Messiah? Probably), Fenno insisted that we sing each note detached, with a strong "H" : ha-ha-ha-ha. We were horrified. It will sound awful, we argued. Just wait, he said. We sang it in Woolsey Hall, a.k.a. Reverberation City. The newspaper critic commented on the "elegant legato singing" by the chorus. Fenno knew just how to play that hall.
 
After decades of the Randall Thompson Alleluia from the second balcony of Woolsey at Commencement, one year Fenno switched to the Biebl Ave Maria. Faculty, deans, and other Commencement regulars were stunned, some near tears. What WAS that piece? William Sloane Coffin asked. (Coffin sang with us in that Beethoven's Ninth.)
 
Fenno worked his magic on generations of new singers, but he was also wonderful with skilled singers. At my Umpteenth Reunion, Fenno conducted a small bunch of us in a performance in Battell of the Biebl, the Mozart Ave Verum Corpus, and some other pieces. We all remembered the music and could put it together in one rehearsal, so Fenno spent much of the time talking about the nuances of this music, sharing insights from having lived inside this music for such a long time.
 
A lifetime spent creating beauty is a great achievement. We should all aspire to such generosity.
 
Jim Meehan
JE '71, GRD '76

Love Story

Dear Fenno, Carol, and the Heaths,



Where to start? It's fair to say that you, Fenno, are personally responsible for our 20 years of couplehood, 15 years of marriage, and two wonderful (and musical!) children. We met in the Freshman Chorus, grew to be friends in the Glee Club, and started dating during our senior year, when we served as President and Business Manager. (As we recall, you were more or less clueless about our romantic relationship, though Georgia Whitney sussed it out early on....) As you always loved to say, "the best friendships are made through singing," and we couldn't agree more.



We of course have special musical memories from our YGC years -- beautiful Heath originals like "Fern Hill," spirited renditions of the football medley, thrilling spirituals with great soloists like Sonya and Dave, sublime choral classics from Bach to Bruckner to Berlioz. And then there are those quirky, memorable moments from rehearsals, concerts, tours -- your gleeful gestures at a sudden modulation, your perfect balance of withering disdain (when we stunk) and heartfelt gratitude (when we soared), your remarkable ability to conduct with your eyeglasses. It was a particular pleasure to work with you as part of the officer corps, to see how deeply you cared about the YGC, its members, and its history.



But perhaps our most treasured experience with you came when you graciously agreed to conduct the chorus at our wedding in 1993. When we first approached you with the idea, you eagerly accepted, declaring that our ceremony sounded a lot like your daughters': "a concert, with a little wedding on the side." You conducted the Durufle "Ubi caritas" and your own setting of 1 Corinthians 13, "The Greatest of These Is Love." We'd assembled an all-star chorus for you, made up of friends from high school, Yale, and New York, including soloists from YGC, the Whiffs, the Alley Cats, and the Metropolitan Opera. The combination of their voices, your conducting, and your amazing music was by far the highlight of the ceremony -- a breathtaking way to begin our marriage. We also remember how touched we and the singers were when, after the rehearsal run-through of the Corinthians piece (the first time this particular group had ever sung together), you dropped your hands, smiled, and announced, "Well, that's just about how I wrote it." We could imagine no higher compliment from a composer.



We've loved seeing you and Carol occasionally over the last few years, and we regret that we weren't able to see you more often. As we sing with Sam and Ellie, we think of you, and we remain ever thankful that we walked up the stairs in Hendrie Hall those many years ago. It was a rare privilege singing with you and knowing you, and you will always be with us.



Much love,



Juliette and Jeff Hyson '89

Graceful and easy Maestro

Fenno,

You always challenged us to sing our best.

Your assuming that we could sing that way, inspired us.

Sometimes approaching your expectations, we glimpsed beauty that you knew.

Graceful and easy Maestro, we can't forget the joy in music we discovered following your cue.

Bob Burke '67

You are a most beloved man

Dear Fenno,

Whenever I think of you, thrilling Hendrie Hall memories come rushing back -- and of a sudden I am with you there again, experiencing the joy of expressing in song what it is to be alive, here, now, together, this moment. So many truthful things you shared with us!

When I left the YGC to conduct the Yale Women's Slavic Chorus, you welcomed me as a peer, and I did my best to pass on what you taught us about song, human striving for excellence, cooperation, and sound's ordered beauties. And joy. Oh the joy. You have enriched my life, and so many lives, in untold ways. Thank you for all of it.

Today as I open Carol's message, in my heart I am back in my Hendrie Hall seat again, with dear companions, sight reading the alto part to your Fern Hill and hearing those chords move through the air for the first magical time.

Thank you for your music, for the respect and love you have given us to pass on, in turn, to others, for your humor, for your sharp musical wit and lyrical brilliance.

You are a most beloved man and your song is in our hearts forever.


Laura Hendrickson
PC '83

And When From Death I'm Free, I'll Sing On


Dear Fenno,

You made me glad during my four years at Yale. With you, I got to sing magnificent music, winsome melodies, rousing cheers and teasing ditties. You led us with wit, passion, exasperation, faith and a good humor that winked at us from under your fierce looks. We all loved you for caring so much, not only about the music, but also about each member of your glee club. And we continue to love you, appreciating how you have remembered us long past our undergraduate days. Thank you for investing your life in people and in making music with them. Your have built something in our hearts that lasts, and sings on.

And when from death I’m free, I’ll sing on,
I’ll sing on,
And when from death I’m free I’ll sing on.
And when from death I’m free
I’ll sing and joyful be,
And through eternity I’ll sing on,
I’ll sing on,
And through eternity I’ll sing on.

God bless you, Fenno.

Love,
Sarah Congdon Leech
(Morse, ’80)

SarahCongdon@aya.yale.edu

'Neath the memories

Summer 1980....somewhere in Austria (Graz?).  Not our official concert, but an impromptu standup of Randall Thompson's Alleluja after a group dinner, as a gesture for our hosts.  It had been a long day, involving long bus rides, a hike to a glacier, return hike in pouring rain, and then the ride back to town on the "disco bus" with the cooperative bus driver flashing the interior lights as we danced in the aisle.  Fenno was on another bus...  I suppose we had a little adrenaline, followed by wine with dinner.  The basses decided it would be fun to - fully on purpose this time - add the "wrong" first descending "alleluja."...the one that feels like it should be in the score on the first page, but isn't, and that takes repeated reminders to rehearse out.  We were quite loud about it.  I remember Fenno looking right at our table and mouthing the words, "That's not funny,"  as he continued directing.  The next day he was more dour than usual on the bus (sort of a permanent state, after listening to the tape of Styx singing "Lady" far too many times).  After a tense, quite ride for many miles, Fenno took the bus microphone and lectured us about respecting our hosts, the music, and each other.  He was right of course.  I never regretted a silly joke more than at that moment.  Fenno, thanks for all the incredible times, lessons, fun, and friends.
 
Brent Sherwood, '80

Thursday, December 4, 2008

Good Night, Mr. O'Heath

Carol and I were at Smith together and we would come to New Haven on weekends and Carol would stay at my house. My grandmother lived with us and when Fenno would come to pick Carol up, Grandma would greet him warmly with, "Good morning, Mr. O'Heath." We never corrected her. With deep love,
Bobbsie Hyman Granger

More Fenno Memories

What a gift your family has given us by allowing us to share all these memories with you and with each other. As I sit at my computer, I am listening to the Yale Glee Club album (yes, we still have a turntable), and periodically refreshing the blog site to read other postings. So many of the Fenno-isms are right on target, and bring back such vivid memories.


I have such a clear mental image of that I-just-ate-a-mealy-apple face as you listened to a particular sloppy passage, rubbing the fingers of one hand together as if that would somehow clean up the mess we were making. And of you pointing to the alto section (which actually meant pointing to where the altos would have been had they not been standing mixed), always with that insistent finger, trying to get more of that all-important 3rd-of-a-chord from them. And the hand flying this way and that, with or without the glasses dangling from the fingers, often crashing into the music stand as you made some insistent point about phrasing or pronunciation. And the warm-ups (eeyaw, eeyaw) with jaw lax, or jowls shaking. And the energy with which you sat down (and stood up!) to play the football medley. And as mentioned elsewhere, those few strands of hair you would pull straight up, to try to get us back in tune.


Glee Club reunions only feel like Glee Club reunions when you're there, Fenno. You can hear that we're all missing you already, but your music and your influence will live on, even longer than the Glee Club albums which some of us still listen to when we want to go back a little in time.


Mark J. Polisar, '84

Auditions

Fenno, Carol and all,

I went upstairs to find my Fenno buttons and found that I still have four of them. I wore them on each coat while at school, and certainly for every concert, so it was important to have a few extra. I have them out and about the house tonight.

Many others have done such an eloquent job at recounting specifics from Yale – the tours, the concerts, the rehearsals, the “who wrote this?” we would hear from you as we sang yet another of your tasteful modulations in a piece you composed! I wanted to recount something more recent to me, the “Fenno-fest” from March 2004 where you came to Washington, DC to conduct a group of alumni as you had done repeatedly over the years. I hadn’t been singing extensively since I left Yale, other than coming back for reunions and singing dinners, but came along excitedly. It had been 17 years since singing at Yale, and a while since I had seen you last, and you looked older. However, as you got us to warm up and rehearse the music we were to sing that Sunday, and in your usual wonderful way chastised us when we couldn’t quite get a piece or two the first time through, the years melted away from you and from us. You had that same exuberance and excitement that we all knew and loved so well, and that’s what we all saw the rest of the weekend. Following that wonderful experience, I found a local choir in which to start singing. Clay Kaufman got me involved in the YGCA again, and I started singing a capella with Clay and a few other brave and gallant bandoleros here in DC. So even as a an alum you got me singing again, doing something I had missed for a long time. We think warm wishes for all of you from DC, and I think how those years would still melt away if we were able to get you to conduct us all once more.

Marty Brennan, ’87

Martin J. Brennan, III
Vice President and Managing Director Management Solutions

Washington Consulting, an Alion Company

Suite 450, Spring Hill Drive, Vienna, VA 22182

Office 703-752-7626 Mobile 703-587-7454 Fax 703-752-7678
mbrennan@washingtonconsulting.com

"The Greatest of These is Love"

The Greatest of These is Love

Before I even came to Yale, I knew about the singing. Oh how I knew about the singing. One of my greatest dreams was to "get into" the Yale Glee Club. The happy day I learned that I was accepted into YGC, I told my father, Ronald Roseman, who was a colleague of Fenno's at the Yale School of Music, and he shared my excitement. He knew how much it meant to me and how wonderful an experience I was going to have singing under Fenno.

And wonderful experience I did have.

I learned so much from you musically, Fenno. How to make music, versus sing notes; how to breathe (or not!); how to since everything from spirituals to Berlioz to Ives to Yales songs to Heath…; how to sing oh-so-much better; how to sing ("How do they do it?") and how to SING.

But I experienced much more than "just" the wonderful music and singing. Through you and YGC, I made fantastic, life-long friends—my fellow YGCers, YGC alumni, other Yalies, you and Carol and your family …. Fenno and Carol, you welcomed us all into your family. And I have no idea how you did it, but you never seemed to forget any of our names. After 39 years, that's a lot of names! I travelled to exotic locales with the Glee Club—Europe, East and West, on my first trip out of the US (ex-Canada), all up and down New England; and of course, the Industrial Cities Winter Tour, for which I was the proud co-Tour Manager with Matt Ringel. And after a turbulent and emotional first-semester experience with Whim, for whom I left YGC to pursue a "glamourous" singing group experience, you welcomed me back into YGC for my second semester with open arms, love, and nary a scolding. Thank you.

Fenno, thank you for giving me the gift of making me part of the Yale Glee Club.

Fenno, thank you also for your music. Thank you for arranging the Yale Songs in SATB! Thank you for recognizing, enabling and promoting that women singing in the Glee Club would be a good thing. Without you, I may never have gotten the chance to experience—and still experience for the rest of my life through the Yale Alumni Chorus—the joys of choral singing with Yalies.

Thank you too for your own beautiful compositions—"Cascade", "Tiger, Tiger", "The Lamb", "Fern Hill"…to name a few. Your pieces are always a joy to sing, and the endings are always, well, so unmistakably "Fenno". I always particularly enjoyed singing your beautiful setting of Corinthians. There are so many parts in that piece where the harmonies and melodies make me feel like I am soaring on heavenly air—the music is so beautiful. "The greatest of these is love…" Indeed. Fenno and Carol, thank you for sharing your love with us, through your music, through your family, through your friendship, through your hearts. Fenno, we will always love you.

With Much Love,
Rémie Roseman Christ
Yale '91
YGC 1988 - 1991
remiekim@remiekim.com

Fenno's French Professor at Yale Remembers

Dear Fenno, I so admire you and recall my time with the YGC and its members very fondly. I cannot walk through Grand Central Terminal without thinking about incredible experiences with you as our beloved teacher. But you also had teachers. The story below comes from my father's cousin, Mrs. Annabeth Perls, who lives in Pacific Palisades. She is a pianist, a marvelous singer in her own right, and was your French teacher at Yale. She related this story to me by phone, and sends her best wishes to you and your family. Jim Lande '87

(Annabeth Perls, interviewed by phone) "Fenno was brilliant as a student. I was myself a graduate student at Yale. Here I was, not much older than my students. It was Fenno's freshmen class. I gave him the assignment and called on him and he trotted up with his fellow student and brought out a flute or something. They did their homework, see, not knowing I was a musician. They had translated their French homework into music, and turned the assignment into some versification, and they thought they were playing a joke on me. At this point the class had only had perhaps four weeks of French. I was enchanted! It was the very best thing anyone could have done. (Q. What were you doing at Yale?) I was a 1st or 2nd year graduate student working on my thesis. It would have been Fenno's freshman year. There were two women taking their master's in Romance Languages. Henri Peyer was the great teacher there in the department. But the person I really loved was Jean Boosch; he was still alive a few years ago when he turned 100, perhaps he is still living now. I was a graduate assistant under Professor Boosch. He had initiated the teaching system where you speak French from the first day. We did not use English. This was the first time anyone had used such a method in class. The students would have to learn their vocabulary and grammar at home and there was not much theory. This was the way to teach the military officers who were at Yale who were going to France and had to learn to speak French in three months. We drowned them in French. This worked well, so it went over into the general curriculum. I remember Fenno very well. He was very handsome, among other things. He was very talented. I think I had him in class for a year. His companion (in the flute episode) had a mono-syllabic Chinese-sounding name, although he wasn't Chinese, he was Caucasian. I could pick out his name if I saw a list. I arrived at Yale in the Fall of 1943, so the class with Fenno must have been in 1944 or 1945. (Q. So the assignment Fenno did was performed entirely in French?) Yes, en français. Absolument ! The funny thing, I don't think Fenno (and his classmate) had a clue that music was my passion. (Q. Did he get a good grade?) They got a good grade. They deserved it, they did great work! [Anne Perls can be e-mailed at aeperls@roadrunner.com Transcribed for Fenno's blog by Jim Lande, '87]

Thanks for the Memories

Dear Fenno --

What I remember most is that you made the extraordinary ordinary, and that is a great thing. You took a bunch of kids from who knows where and exposed us to the kinds of experiences that most people never even dream of. Sing at Carnegie Hall? Have private sessions with Robert Shaw? Do a concert with Victor Borge? Travel the world and sing as the Berlin Wall was crumbling down? All in a day's work for the YGC. And it was fun, not intimidating.

Besides the wonderful musical gifts, it gave so many people the poise and the confidence to go forth and aspire to and hopefully accomplish great things. This spirit lives on the the Yale Alumni Chorus, which also makes the extraordinary ordinary. I can only hope I can inspire just one person on to greatness as you did for so many.

Thank you and Godspeed.

Lily Giordano '90

O, why does time so quickly fly?

As last night's dress rehearsal stretched on, and students began to lose their focus and chatter when we needed quiet, I heard myself saying, with a grin, "I love you. Now shut up."  This was not the first time I've said these words to a group of students who both thrill me and drive me berserk.  I had always thought the words were mine, but today I read them on this blog and learned that they were Fenno's, lodged deep somewhere in my musical soul.  Once, many years ago, they must have been directed at me and my rambunctious singing friends, but it's only now that I recognize how real the sentiments were.  Like a new mother who suddenly discovers the depth of love her own parents must hold for her, it is only when we become teachers (conductors, directors) ourselves that we learn how deeply our own mentors cared for us.  Students come and go, and are replaced every year with a fresh batch of potential, but the connection is deep nonetheless.

Fenno, you were probably around the age I am now when I came into your office and challenged you to take me on as your first female assistant, the first young woman to direct the Freshman Chorus.  I may have been frightened and full of self-doubt, but I know that I presented myself as a cocky know-it-all who deserved to be taken seriously.  The temptation to put me in my place must have been enormous.  Instead, you treated me with respect and decency, giving me the freedom to experiment and learn from my mistakes.  You gave me free reign and support with the freshmen, and let me conduct the Glee Club in a complex Bach motet on our tour of Central America, though prudence would have urged you to give me something requiring less musical maturity.  (I wish I could find the news clipping from one of the countries we visited, with a photo and caption which must have galled you as much as it amused you: a photo of me conducting the Glee Club, captioned with YOUR name, misspelled: "Seno Health".  What made it even worse - "seno" means "breast" in Spanish!)

When I was at Yale I probably felt more connected to your daughter Lucy, with whom I played viols, then I did to you.  So full of my recent discovery of early music, I didn't fully recognize the gifts you gave me or acknowledge your generous mentorship.  Last night, as your words came out in rehearsal, I was reminded once again of the deep and lasting effect you have had on me as a teacher and musician.  Thank you, Fenno, for what you have given to so many countless young musicians - more than we ever realized.

Sarah Mead, '75

Enthusiastic Singer

Fenno --
 
I came to Yale because I heard the Glee Club sing at an event in Buffalo, NY (it must have been a dreary Winter tour that year!). "Fern Hill" was on the program and it remains one of my favorite things we sang in the Glee Club.
 
I may have entered Yale an enthusiastic singer, but I left Yale a committed choral singer and have sung in choruses ever since and I thank you and your enthusiasm for us undergraduate singers for this ever life-enriching transformation.
 
Yours,
Steven Ralston, '85

Prince of the Apple Towns

Fenno, Carol, Sarah, and Family –
 
Not a day goes by that we don't have that Fenno moment – that inspiration to draw music from our hearts and to follow, yet again, the man who got us there… often in spite of ourselves.
 
Fenno, you are, and will remain, Prince of the Apple Towns!
 
And because you helped define what we find there, you will always be in our hearts!
 
Rest easy, Friend!
Much Love,
John Burke, '72
 
AIG Global Reinsurance Division
180 Maiden Lane, 20th Floor
New York, NY  10038
646-433-5722
 

Prayers

There will be prayers from here that our beloved leader may have a good entrance into larger life.  My three years in the Yale Glee Club were deeply formative of my life, and I have sung everywhere I have been, most recently with the Sewanee Chorale, doing the baritone solos in the Messiah and the Brahms Requiem.  Fenno's impact on so many of us, in musicianship, character, and faith is wide and deep.  Roll, Jordan, Roll.

Bob, YGC, 63-66

The Rev. Robert D. Hughes, III, Ph.D.
Norma and Olan Mills Professor of Divinity
Professor of Systematic Theology
School of Theology
Sewanee: The University of the South

Electric Moment

Fenno
 
I passed through Yale and the Glee Club during the David Connell years. It was always an electric moment when we found out that we would be singing one of your pieces, or better yet, when you would be popping in to check on our progress.
 
I can't remember which of your arrangments I had the privilege to sing first. But I do remember the piece for the inauguration of President Levin. Putting that music together was one of my fondest memories as a YGC singer. There came a moment in time when all of those Fenno-type chords and transitions (which initally, to be honest, made absolutely no sense to me) finally gelled into a spine-tingling beautful melody--a dynamic journey within which the music lifted on the page and came to life. I still carry all of those chords and transitions in my head and find myself humming that inauguration piece at very random times.
 
I now find myself back in New Haven, and with the nostalgia for my YGC years as strong as ever, I can see you standing in the balcony of Woolsey, after finishing one of your pieces, humbly accepting the admiration of your family, your fellow singers, and all those who had experienced your masterpieces as audience members.
 
Thank you for touching so many lives with your gifts. Thank for crfeating my all-time favorite moments in singing (the peak of Shenandoah, the big key change in Antigone--I'm listening to all of them today with tears of joy!)
 
My thoughts are with you and your family.
 
Dave Walker '96

Thanks

So many Yale legends fade away or say goodbye and continue their lives elsewhere.  Fenno continued to be a presence.  My favorite songs from YGC - Fern Hill, The Lamb - songs that are so part of my consciousness that I dream of them, and can be uplifted for a full day when I wake up humming them - thank you for those.  And thank you for my glimpses of glee club history - guest conducting here and there, leading us in song at YGC reunions, and conducting rehearsals during my college reunion.  I read other folks' posts on the blog, and I have my own memories - the tiny tugs to urge us to tune, warm smiles when the chords finally clicked into place - thank you (all) for reaching beyond the generations of glee clubbers who were directly your charge, and continuing to give of yourself.  Thank you.

Sincerely,
Shana (Katz) Ross '00